Montreal pit bull ban brings concern to Western Canada

Tucker and Max, Cody Neale’s two pit bulls, sit for their photo to be taken.

Dog Attacks

In Canada and the USA over the past 32 years, an average of 106 injuries per year have occurred from a pit bull. Since they are known as dogs with bad temperaments, they are currently banned in Montreal.

What does the banning of the breed mean for those here in Southern Alberta?

Banning pit bulls could mean more of them showing up in shelters here.

Due to the fact that people in Montreal are against the ban, they could try to find refuge for those pit bulls still in shelters.

ADVERTISEMENT

“It might affect animal shelters in Alberta because those who are for banning pit bulls will stop adopting them out of shelters. People who are against this ban might go out and adopt more pit bull style breeds to show Quebec they are good dogs they just need the right owner,” said Stephanie Johnson, student veterinary technician.

Would banning a certain breed be something that works?

Cody Neale, corrections officer and fourth year student, doesn’t believe so.

“Pit bulls are smart, loving dogs. Instead of banning the breed, we should be banning those owners from owning dogs”.

Neale, is also the owner of two pit bulls and has never had a problem with them.

Believing it’s all in how the dog is raised, each dog has different temperaments which can be contributing factors.

“I’ve dealt with a lot of amazing pit bulls and I was actually more nervous of certain shepherds and even Chihuahuas, so I think banning a certain breed is ridiculous because it all depends on their history and the owners. Any dog can be viscious if they haven’t been socialized as puppies and growing up,” said Johnson.

If put in the shoes of a Montreal pit bull owner, Laura Serafini, doesn’t know what she’d do.

“If my dog’s breed was to be banned I would be very angry and upset. I believe the way a dog reacts has to do completely with the owner.”, said Serafini.

Even though Serafini doesn’t own a pit bull, but a blood hound crossed with black and tan hound, both dogs can be vicious if not socialized and trained right, as hounds are used for hunting.

“There’s a reason why dogs are referred to as man’s best friend but you as the owner need to take responsibility for it and the actions it makes. The same goes for any dog. Why would we ban a specific breed in a city [Montreal], that’s just silly”, said Serafini.

Currently the ban has been suspended until further notice.

Copyright © 2015. All Rights Reserved. No part of this website may be reproduced without written consent. Please contact news@lethbridgecampusmedia.ca for more information. We encourage all readers to share their comments on our stories, photos, video, audio, blogs, columns and opinion pieces. Due to the nature of the academic program, comments will be moderated and will not be published if they contain personal attacks, threats of violence, spam or abuse. Please visit our editorial policy page for more information.
Authors

Kayla has always had a passion and an interest in radio and journalism from a young age. Her future aspirations include working across North America as well as overseas. She is currently in her second year of Digital Communications and Media at Lethbridge College with a focus on Digital Journalism. Her keen interest in writing and public speaking stems from the age of seven when she joined her local 4-H club. During her 11 years in 4-H, she competed in many public speaking events, including a provincial competition in her home province of British Columbia. In her spare time, Kayla likes to go out hunting, camping and be out in the backwoods in her hometown of Jaffray.

Top